Material Connection of the Day: Peanut Butter Cookies From J. Dorian Chocolatier

j dorian peanut butter cookiesToday we received a basket of peanut butter cookies from J. Dorian, welcoming us to our new offices. Dorian Isenberg, as you know, is one of our very best friends. He likes to bring us cupcakes and chocolate chip cookies. When I stopped by his shop recently–I was taking some white cupcakes with raspberry filling to a baby shower–I told him that I thought it was a real bummer that no one could make a decent peanut butter cookie. Most of the time they are too dry or too sweet. (Do you know of a place? Let me know.) Then I asked if he had thought about adding PB to his repertoire. He assured me he was working out the final recipe. And today we’re taste-testing.

The texture is perfect–the right balance of crumbly and moist. And here’s a revelation–it actually tastes like peanut butter, as opposed to some overly sweet sugar-dusted, dried-out hunk of cardboard. The verdict: “The best peanut butter cookie I’ve ever eaten,” declared one Web-ette. I concur. Later I will report how well they freeze, because that’s where they’re going–straight to my freezer to pull out on another rainy day.


  • shelbyg75

    I love J Dorian 🙂

  • RB

    doughmonkey had a pb&j cookie that was pretty great.

  • JB

    Now I’m definitely going to make a trip there…However, after the great cupcake, I have high expectations for the perfect peanut butter cookie.

  • Julie Blacklidge

    I cannot believe how perfectly he managed a gooey peanut buttery center and still made it light. All of us that had a taste on the 22nd floor concur. Best peanut butter cookie ever.

  • DallasChocolateLover

    They are certainly the “Perfect” peanut butter cookie. I stopped in the other day and tasted his brownie. OMG!!! I needed a moment to myself.

  • Kathie G.


  • Lori

    I guess, I’m weird. I still like the Otis Spunkmeyer cookies they made at my apartment complex hospitality room.

  • DallasDude

    Rest in piece doughmonkey.