Friday, February 3, 2023 Feb 3, 2023
37° F Dallas, TX
Best Lists

The Best Sandwiches in Dallas

In an effort to find the perfect combination of meats, cheeses, and condiments, we went all over Dallas (and Fort Worth, too), tasting the best stuff between bread. From BBQ to BLT, these are the 10 tastiest around.
By D Magazine |

Kathleen’s Art Cafe’s meatloaf sandwich.

ANGELO’S: Sliced Beef
brisket is U.S. Choice or better, slow cooked and served “Texas style”
with mustard, pickles, onions, and some of the best barbecue sauce
around. Of course, simple geography plays a big role—at Angelo’s,
almost every human transaction reminds you of why you love the Lone
Star State. 2533 White Settlement Rd., Fort Worth. 817-332-0357.

BAGELSTEIN’S: Brisket and Chopped Liver on Rye
local Jewish delis don’t measure up to New York standards. But
Bagelstein’s does it right: toothsome rye bread is stacked with thick
slices of tender, slow-roasted brisket and topped with chopped liver of
the perfect consistency. Add a little deli mustard and enjoy. The cost?
$8.95 plus medical expenses. 8100 N. Dallas Pkwy., Plano. 972-712-3050.

JIMMY’S FOOD STORE: Cuban Sandwich
There are a lot of good
reasons to visit this tiny neighborhood treasure, most of them Italian,
including delicious imported cheeses and homemade sausage. Oddly, our
favorite of those reasons—Jimmy’s classic version of the media noche—is not Italian at all. Thin slices of roasted pork and ham, Swiss cheese, and pickles are layered with mojo criollo and toasted in a Cuban press. ¡Fantastico! 4901 Bryan St. @ Fitzhugh Ave. 214-823-6180.

KATHLEEN’S ART CAFE: Meatloaf Sandwich
It ain’t
pretty—layers of mayo, ketchup, lettuce, and tomato beneath two thick
slices of meatloaf on fresh bread tend to bottom out after the first
bite. Nevertheless, the spicy concoction justifies every dry cleaning
bill. 4424 Lovers Ln. 214-691-2355.

Pound for pound—and it weighs
about a pound, easily enough for two—this may be Dallas’ best sandwich
value at $5.50. Spicy as hell (it is, after all, built around a poblano
pepper) and loaded with melted white Mexican queso, avocado, tomato,
and onion, it’s a perfect balance of flavor, texture, and heat of both
kinds. 5611 Maple Ave. (It’s hard to find. Look for the sign with the word “Tortas.”) 214-688-0236.

A hefty wedge of grilled pink salmon
on toasted sourdough, piled with plenty of comforting bacon, lettuce,
tomato, and Brie, has elevated the pedestrian BLT to regal status.
Topped off with vermouth garlic butter and surrounded by crisp fries,
it’s a hearty meal—and a bargain at $10.95. 500 Crescent Ct. 214-999-1222.

PHILLY CONNECTION: Original Cheesesteak
Headquartered in
Atlanta, of all places, Philly Connection knows how to do it right.
Lean meat is griddled with onions and peppers and popped into a steamy,
soft roll. The best place to enjoy one is from a cart way out on the
third base line at the ballpark in Frisco, but if you’re not up for a
game, the chain has 11 stores around town. Dr Pepper/ Seven Up Ballpark, 7300 RoughRiders Tr., Frisco. 972-731-9200. Multiple locations.

Freshly baked
turkey breast, grilled onion, mild and sweet cherry peppers (or
jalapeños), combined with an excellent barbecue sauce and optional
cheese, make a marvelously messy creation on grilled French bread. 3848 Oak Lawn Ave., Ste 190. 214-526-2505.

URBANO PANINOTECA: Portabello Panini
small, stylish Uptown sandwich shop is perfect for a relaxing lunch
break on a hectic day. And the meaty mushrooms topped with spinach,
thyme, roasted red pepper, and Parmesan pressed in ultra-fresh, crusty
ciabatta bread is a vegetarian’s dream. Crisp, seasoned matchstick
fries make a tasty accompaniment. 2418 Fairmount St. 214-969-6911.

The new kid downtown doesn’t make
the typical hard-boiled eggs tossed in Hellman’s and French’s—this
version is a little like a New York-style fried egg sandwich. They
start their egg salad with a soft-boiled egg, which cooks harder as it
moves on a conveyor through the toaster. The process gives the egg a
layered texture, a new and subtle blend of white and yolk that improves
on one of life’s most familiar foods, particularly when you add mayo,
salt, and pepper. 1410 Main St. 214-741-9424.

Local adman and freelance writer Spencer Michlin likes to eat.


Related Articles


The Dallas Dozen

We salute the city's most important players in 2011. They made a difference and inspired others to do the same.
By Jeanne Prejean

Souvenir of Dallas

"The Mighty, Mighty Hands of Mayor Tom Leppert"