Less Than $50 Your relationship status would read “It’s complicated” if you documented your life on Facebook. You know things like his middle name, but you’re unsure about his shirt size. You’re looking for a gift that says “I like you, but I don’t want to meet your parents—yet.”
(clockwise from top) The Singleton of Glendullan single malt Scotch whisky ($45/Goody Goody), Diesel underwear ($20/Skivvies), Bella Muse greeting card ($6.50/Grange Hall), Kiehl’s Original Musk fragrance spray ($38.50/Kiehl’s), chocolate-covered cherry popcorn ($6.95/Candy Corn’s), The Padrón Family Reserve No. 45 Maduro cigar ($25/City Cigars, 3001 Knox St. 214-528-5700), Ashton VSG Series Belicoso cigar ($14/City Cigars, 3001 Knox St. 214-528-5700)
$50 to $150 You can really see a future with this guy, and you’re pretty sure he feels the same way about you. He’s got his own ringtone on your phone, and you’ve got a toothbrush at his place. It’s pretty serious. Even if you’ve been together awhile—and you’re saving your pennies for a trip to Thailand next year—you still want to spoil your sweetie.
(clockwise from top) The Big Book of Legs ($65/Grange Hall), D.L. & Co. Lady Rhubarb candle ($135/Nest), Furni “Gator SE” clock in dark mahogany ($108/We Are 1976), Gucci by Gucci fragrance ($57/Nordstrom), Diptyque (RED) candle ($68/Forty Five Ten)
$150 and beyond You’ve moved past the sickening nicknames (thank god), although you’re guilty of an occasional “babe” or “honey.” He’s your rock, and you still love pampering him, so he deserves the moon.
(clockwise from top) Louis XIII Cognac ($2,100/Sigel’s, Centennial, Majestic), Renzo Romagnoli shaving set ($429/Nest), Max Verre loafers ($725/Hadleigh’s), Hermés vintage pocket square ($195/Hadleigh’s)
Less Than $50 If you’ve just started dating, then you’re not sure what kind of gift you’re obligated to buy. (It would be a lot easier if you had met her after Valentine’s Day.) But you’ve got to pick up something because you like the girl. These ideas are also good if she told you “no gifts this year.” That’s just code for “don’t spend a fortune.” Never, ever show up empty-handed.
(clockwise from left) Blush “Lace and Ruffle” bottoms ($20/Anthropologie), NARS polish in Purple Rain ($16/Sephora), Bubble perfume bottle ($48/Anthropologie), Nicole hearts Love Your Life nail polish ($7.99/Ulta), Too Faced Retractable Kabuki brush ($30/Uptown Makeup), Love, Etc. perfume ($29.50/The Body Shop), Dogeared “Key to My Heart” necklace in gold ($40/Nasher Sculpture Center store)
$50 to $150She’s sugar and spice and everything nice—the majority of the time, anyway. I mean, she puts up with you, so she’s earned something beautiful for V-Day. Even if money’s a bit tight, you remember what happened last year when you didn’t get it right, so you definitely don’t want to do that again.
(clockwise from top) Lola Marc Jacobs fragrance ($85/Sephora), Mariage Fréres Sweetheart Tea ($85/Grange Hall), Shawlsmith London scarf ($85/Betty Reiter), dog bowl and treats ($85 for bowl and $2 per dipped dog treat/Tails of the City), Jarma vintage Czech chandelier crystal necklaces ($firstname.lastname@example.org), La Prairie Life Threads in Gold and Silver ($125/Neiman Marcus), Tocca Stella perfume ($68/Anthropologie), Stella McCartney’s StellaNude fragrance ($81/Sephora)
$150 and beyondYou’ll make her your wifey when the time is right. But for now, she can have anything she wants. If she’s already your better half, then show her how much you care (read: no golf clubs).
(clockwise from top) Prada peep-toe in nude pink ($730/Neiman Marcus), arrangement with white hydrangea, red roses, white orchids, white casablanca lilies, and tea leaves ($150/Apples to Zinnias), Guerlain Elixirs Charnels perfume in Gourmand Coquin, Chypre Fatal, Oriental Brûlant, and Boisé Torride($250/Neiman Marcus), Hadleigh's cashmere and linen scarf ($495/Hadleigh's) Christian Louboutin Peep-Toe “Bananna” pump in coral ($735/Neiman Marcus), Daniele Cornaggia red leather skin clutch ($1,270/Betty Reiter)